This guide helps organise a review. It is not a retention schedule or legal advice. An agency’s role, jurisdiction and contracts matter. Obtain privacy advice before setting rules for a live workflow.
Start with purpose, not file age
The GDPR’s storage-limitation principle ties retention to the processing purpose. A vacancy application, a talent-pool profile and an employee record should not inherit one blanket expiry date. The European Commission explains the principle. Record why each category remains necessary and when that reason will be reviewed.
Separate candidate records from employee records
When an applicant joins, review which information belongs in the employment workflow. Interview notes, CV attachments, identity copies and payroll records do not automatically share a purpose. An agency placing a worker and an employer hiring that worker should each identify their responsibilities.
Talent pools need a distinct decision
Keeping a CV for future roles is a different use from assessing one vacancy. Explain that use, establish a lawful basis and document its review point. Where consent is relied on, it must meet the GDPR’s requirements and be withdrawable. Consent is not an indefinite permission to keep every copy. The Dutch Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens provides applicant-specific guidance, including keeping information longer with permission. Check its context rather than treating employer guidance as a universal agency rule.
Do you need the identity document?
Do not request or retain an identity copy simply because a folder has space for it. Establish which stage and obligation require which information. The Dutch regulator distinguishes information needed during an application from information needed on employment. Restrict access to identity documents and avoid copying them into general shortlists.
A review worksheet for copies outside the ATS
Illustrative example: a recruiter exports a shortlist, emails it to a manager and saves CVs in a shared folder. Removing the ATS profile would not by itself prove those copies were reviewed. Use the following worksheet with category labels rather than real candidate data.
| Review item | Record before deciding |
|---|---|
| ATS profile | Vacancy or talent-pool purpose, owner and review trigger |
| Mailbox attachment | Recipient, duplicate status, access and deletion responsibility |
| Shared shortlist | Folder owner, external sharing and continuing need |
| Identity document | Specific necessity, restricted location and applicable obligation |
| Exception | Reason, limited scope, approver and next review date |
Run a repeatable review
- Inventory systems and destinations for downloaded or forwarded records.
- Group records by purpose and role, not just file extension.
- Have the responsible professional approve the rule and exception route.
- Give system owners bounded review tasks.
- Record decisions, approvals, completion evidence and unresolved copies.
- Schedule the next review and revisit rules when workflows change.
Common mistakes and when to seek help
Common operational gaps include assuming ATS deletion covers email, using talent-pool consent for every purpose, transferring entire candidate folders to HR, and keeping disputed records indefinitely without a review owner. The EDPB recommends purpose-specific retention policies and deletion procedures.
Seek a privacy professional when an employment duty, legal claim, erasure request or cross-border role creates uncertainty. An exception should be scoped and documented; it should not become a reason to keep every unrelated copy.
Where automation could help
Monitoring could surface review tasks and track completion against approved rules. It cannot determine every lawful retention period from age alone. Trace is validating this concept for candidate data outside the ATS; no recruitment connector or deletion product is live.
Discuss a recruitment retention pilot
Related: retention monitoring concept and privacy-request preparation.
Sources and editorial responsibility
Links above point to EU institutions and the Dutch regulator. Trace editorial team maintains this operational guide. Jurisdiction-specific expert review has not been completed. Review the linked guidance and applicable law before making a live-data decision.